The Matilda Effect: the Women erased from science
Throughout history, women have often struggled to get credit for their discoveries and contributions offered to science: their intuitions were frequently downplayed, ignored or attributed to male colleagues. This phenomenon is known as the "Matilda Effect", a term coined by historian of science Margaret W. Rossiter in 1993, in honour of Matilda Joslyn Gage. As a suffragist, writer and activist of the eighteen-hundreds, Gage was one of the first to denounce the lack of recognition of female genius, in her 1870 essay "Woman as Inventor".
One of the cases that perhaps best illustrates this phenomenon is that of Alice Augusta Ball, an African American chemist and the first woman to earn a master's degree at the University of Hawaii. As the page dedicated to her by the National Women's History Museum explains, Alice was born in Seattle in 1892 and earned two degrees at the University of Washington, one in pharmaceutical chemistry in 1912 and one in pharmacy in 1914. In 1915 she obtained a master's in chemistry at the University of Hawaii, becoming the first woman and the first African American to reach this milestone.
At just 23, she became a teacher and researcher at the University of Hawaii, and it was during this period that Dr Harry T. Hollman asked for her help in finding an effective treatment for leprosy. Until then, the only remedy was oil extracted from the seeds of the chaulmoogra tree, which, however, was too thick to be injected and caused severe vomiting when taken orally. Ball developed a technique that isolated the oil's fatty acids and converted them into ethyl esters. This made the substance easy for the body to absorb: Ball had found the first truly effective treatment for leprosy.
Tragically, in 1916, shortly before her scientific discovery was published, Alice Ball died at just 24. Her death certificate lists tuberculosis as the cause of death, although some historians and articles from the time (such as a well-known piece in the Pacific Commercial Advertiser from 1917) suggest that the certificate was likely altered and that Alice in fact fell seriously ill in the laboratory after inhaling chlorine gas.
As reconstructed from the University of Hawaii's historical archives and by the National Women's History Museum, after her death the president of the College of Hawaii, Arthur L. Dean, took up Alice Ball's work and published it, but did not credit Ball, instead taking credit for the research himself; indeed, for years people spoke of the "Dean Method".
It was physician Harry T. Hollmann who broke the silence: in an article published in 1922 in the scientific journal Archives of Dermatology and Syphilology, Hollmann denounced the plagiarism and officially restored Alice's authorship of the treatment, calling it the "Ball Method". Despite this, because of the deep racial and gender discrimination of the time, Alice Ball's scientific achievement would go unrecognised for a full 80 years. Her name was rediscovered at the end of the '90s thanks to an investigation by researchers in the University of Hawaii's archives.
In 2000, the University of Hawaii officially recognised Alice Ball's work by installing a commemorative plaque. On the same day, the government proclaimed 28 February "Alice Ball Day". In 2007, the university posthumously awarded her the Regents' Medal of Distinction, its highest honour.
And today?
While, historically speaking, the names of scientists like Alice Ball are finally emerging from obscurity, in academia and research gender bias continues to show up in structural dynamics. It is not a matter of lack of interest or ability: data from AlmaLaurea's Focus Gender Gap 2025 disprove the idea that women are less suited to scientific subjects. In STEM fields, female graduates achieve a higher average final grade than their male peers (104.5 versus 102.6) and are more likely to complete their studies on time (58.1% versus 52.7%).
However, as one moves from university into the job market and an academic career, a phenomenon known as the leaky pipeline emerges. Although employment rates five years after a STEM degree are high for both genders (90.1% for women and 92.6% for men), clear gaps remain in contracts and pay. In equivalent full-time jobs, female STEM graduates earn on average 12.6% less than their male colleagues (€1,798 net per month versus €2,025) and are more likely to be on fixed-term contracts or research grants.
Alongside this economic disparity comes an undervaluing of women's scientific output. Several academic studies, including research published in Nature Human Behaviour (Huang et al.), point to a citation gap: scientific papers with a female first author receive on average fewer citations than those of their male colleagues.
Acknowledging the Matilda Effect and analysing current data does not mean denying the progress that has been made, but highlighting that full equality in research still requires concrete action, so that scientific talent and merit are valued regardless of gender.
Comments